Toilet cleaning staff: Let me help you!

Part 7 of 7 in the series Bathroom User Experiences.

In public loo’s it is common to find these kinds of quality assessment tools. I have worked with quality assessment at IBM, am an interaction designer and seem to have a general fascination with toilets. So these screens are intriguing to me and I have a feeling that these systems have quite low use and do not accurately measure what they try to.

Some problems

The screens ask for generic feedback on the full experience – toilet, sink and walking/waiting areas. How can they know which part I am rating?

On average, the rating the system show is probably worse than what is reality. We are more likely to give feedback when we are dissatisfied than when all is good.

I might be having a bad day. “Taking it out” on the rating box is an easy way of getting some aggression out of my body.

Most importantly: There is no indication in this system that I will have real impact. My “vote” might cause a reaction of some kind from the cleaning management staff. But there is no indication of that. So, I assume that the voting will just end up in a database somewhere, unused and forgotten.

My suggestion

Ask us to “press a button” when a specific action needs to be taken, such as soap being refilled, a toilet unclogged or a Wunderbaum exchanged.

This would:

  • make the action specific rather than generic
  • make feedback accurate as we never ask if things ar good, just wether they are bad
  • make it more difficult for me to to take “my bad day” out on the system
  • make it clear to me what my “vote” will be used for – someone will hopefully come to the toilet with some more paper :)

By being specific rather than generic the cleaning staff can also use the system as an indication of what to do next, in their workday. They will get a live dashboard of specific actions they can take to make toilet visitors more pleased.

Toilets are seldom sources of joy. But they can be comfortable. A button next to the urinal can help enable that!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We are eating the software creation process

I think a transformation is happening in digital product creation: We ux/product designers are eating the software creation process. It's a good development and your team should take advantage of it. Marc said...

Pac-Man by Namco.

Published in process.

Foundations for better restaurant sites

Part 9 of 9 in the series Deliverables.

Plate with food

To design better restaurant sites I interviewed six persons. From the discussions I got eight insights. Among them are that sites are used by newbies and regulars, that reviews are super valuable, that we want to imagine the restaurant visit before it happens, and more. The insights can help when building new sites/apps or evaluating existing ones. 8 things the site needs to enable